1. Candidates

All the Package Managers that were considered, rejected & selected

Criteria

The following Caveats were applied:

• Must NOT be (Excluded: AUR, GURU, NUR etc.)

• Must have an active development, i.e. no abandonware

• Must have its own with at least 500 Packages & NOT use/rely on a . Learn why we mandate a recipe repository instead of using existing ones at: https://docs.pkgforge.dev/orgs/readme-1/projects/soarpkgs/faq

• We included the top 4 (5) Projects that met the above criteria & had the most number of packages

---

Considered

Date:

Elimination: Anything below 10 stars was ignored & as well archived repos. Anything that has not received any update in the last ~ 2 Years was also ignored.

We ended up with:

• https://github.com/babarot/afx

• https://github.com/ivan-hc/AM (https://github.com/ivan-hc/AppMan)

• https://github.com/cosmic-utils/app-hub

• https://github.com/prateekmedia/appimagepool

• https://github.com/AppImageCrafters/appimage-cli-tool

• https://github.com/marcosnils/bin

• https://github.com/rjbrown57/binman

• https://github.com/anchore/binny

• https://github.com/mitchweaver/bonsai

• https://github.com/pegvin/bread

• https://github.com/brioche-dev/brioche

• https://github.com/vinifmor/bauh

• https://github.com/cask-pkg/cask.rs

• https://github.com/xplshn/dbin

• https://github.com/mijorus/gearlever

• https://github.com/dominiksalvet/gitpack

• https://github.com/aerys/gpm

• https://github.com/innobead/huber

• https://github.com/Rishang/install-release

• https://github.com/txthinking/nami

• https://github.com/zyrouge/pho

• https://github.com/leleliu008/ppkg

• https://github.com/marwanhawari/stew

• https://github.com/srevinsaju/zap

---

Rejected

• babarot/afx : No Recipe Repository & Likely Abandoned
• cosmic-utils/app-hub: No Recipe Repository
• prateekmedia/appimagepool: No Recipe Repository (Uses appimage.github.io) & Likely Abandoned
• AppImageCrafters/appimage-cli-tool: Included here, just for . Completely Abandoned
• marcosnils/bin: Too few "official" recipes, mostly just another eget clone with Package Management
• rjbrown57/binman: No Recipe Repository & just another eget clone with Package Management
• anchore/binny: No Recipe Repository & just another eget clone with Package Management
• mitchweaver/bonsai: Too few "official" recipes
• pegvin/bread: No Recipe Repository (Uses appimage.github.io) & Likely Abandoned
• brioche-dev/brioche: Too few "official" recipes
• vinifmor/bauh: No Recipe Repository (Uses appimage.github.io). This is actually the only one actively maintained appimage manager with a GUI. We recommend it, but we will reject it as it doesn't meet our criteria
• cask-pkg/cask.rs: Too few "official" recipes
• xplshn/dbin: Too few "official" recipes & these are xplshn's own format. (Uses pkforge's metadata). This is actually the only one actively maintained package manager with lots of packages. We recommend it, but we will reject it as it doesn't meet our criteria
• mijorus/gearlever: No Recipe Repository, needs local file
• dominiksalvet/gitpack: Not a regular package manager; Works with Git Repos, but the repos must have a special dir to support it
• aerys/gpm: Not a regular package manager; Works with Git Repos, but requires LFS & other extra steps
• innobead/huber: No Recipe Repository & just another eget clone with Package Management
• Rishang/install-release: No Recipe Repository & just another eget clone with Package Management
• txthinking/nami: Too few "official" recipes
• zyrouge/pho: No Recipe Repository & just another eget clone but for AppImage only
• marwanhawari/stew: No Recipe Repository & just another eget clone with Package Management
• srevinsaju/zap: No Recipe Repository (Uses appimage.github.io) & Likely Abandoned

---

Selected

• ivan-hc/AM: Meets all the criteria & has its own recipe repo
• HomeBrew: Far exceeds all the criteria & has its own recipe repo
• Pacstall: Meets all the criteria & has its own recipe repo
• leleliu008/ppkg: Meets all the criteria & has its own recipe repo
• pkgforge/soar: Well… We don't need to explain this... do we??